Tavessa.

10 warning signs in your product governance, drawn from FCA reviews

Since the Consumer Duty came in, the FCA has published a series of reviews showing what good and weak practice look like. Read side by side, the same weaknesses keep coming up. Here are ten of them, each with its source and a fix a small firm can make.

In short

  • Most warning signs are about evidence: generic statements, untested assumptions and actions nobody checks.
  • The FCA's examples are illustrative and don't create new rules, but they show what supervisors look for.
  • Each fix below is sized for a firm without a dedicated product governance team.

Products and target markets

1. Your target market is one sentence that could describe anyone

Manufacturers must identify a target market at a sufficiently granular level (PRIN 2A.3.4R). In its July 2026 review of 38 firms, the FCA found some target market descriptions were generic, especially for higher-risk products, with no explanation of why that market suited those risks.1

Fix: describe who the product is for in terms of needs, characteristics and objectives, and say why the product's risks suit them.

2. You've never written down who the product is not for

Among the good practice the FCA saw was the use of "negative target markets" to identify customers the product doesn't suit.1

Fix: add a short "not suitable for" list to every product record, and check your promotions and sales routes don't reach those groups.

Monitoring

3. Complaints are your only outcome measure

The FCA flagged a smaller firm that relied mainly on complaint volumes to monitor outcomes as a concern.1 Its board report review also warns that a lack of complaints should not be relied on alone.2

Fix: add two or three behavioural measures, such as early cancellations, product usage or drop-off in a journey, plus what frontline staff are hearing.

4. "Vulnerable customers" is one catch-all group

The FCA criticised board reports that treated customers with vulnerability characteristics as a single group, and some that described strong outcomes the MI didn't support.2

Fix: break results down by the characteristics that matter for your product, such as age, health or low financial resilience, even if the numbers are small.

5. Your thresholds have no rationale

Thresholds set without justification were an area for improvement in the board report review.2

Fix: for each threshold, write one line on why it is set where it is and what happens when it's breached.

Price and value

6. Your "total price" leaves out the charges customers trip over

A fair value assessment must consider the total price customers can expect to pay (PRIN 2A.4.8R). The FCA's October 2026 consumer finance findings flagged assessments that looked at fees separately or left out contingent charges such as arrears charges.3

Fix: map every fee and charge a customer could pay over the product's life, including non-financial costs such as time and effort.

7. Your benchmarking only compares headline prices

The same review flagged benchmarking focused on headline prices, with premium pricing left unexplained.3

Fix: choose comparators you can justify, compare benefits as well as price, and explain any premium in plain words.

Governance and action

8. You make changes but never check whether they worked

Some firms didn't validate whether their changes improved outcomes.1 In the March 2026 consumer understanding review, the FCA said firms must not only monitor but also act on what monitoring reveals.4

Fix: give every change a "how we'll know it worked" measure and a date to check it.

9. Your action plan has no owners or deadlines

Plans without owners, timescales or evidence of effectiveness were a recurring weakness in first-year board reports.2

Fix: keep one action log with an owner, a due date and a status for every item, and review it at every governance meeting.

10. Compliance writes the board report and the board signs it

The FCA saw reports that appeared to be produced mainly by Compliance, and boards acting as a "rubber stamp". Good reports drew input from the business and evidenced board challenge in minutes.2

Fix: ask each product owner to write their own section, and minute at least one challenge per product area.

How to use this list

  • Score each sign red, amber or green for your firm.
  • Pick the two reds that affect the most customers and fix those first.
  • Repeat the check in six months and keep the results as evidence.

Send an enquiry

Your 8-character Companies House number

We'll only use these details to reply to you. See our privacy notice.